Christmas ‘05, when my parents asked what I’d like for a gift, as always, I told them that a new book or two would be just fine. Instead, they bought me a Medieval sword and a pair of Chinese daggers, stating “you already have lots of books.”
They were right, technically; I do have a fair number of books, but since when do parents buy their children weapons instead of educational tools? Had I then been a minor, a call to the Child Protection Services would not have been unwarranted.
This past Christmas I repeated my desire for book gifts saying, “I would like books for Christmas, but if you end up buying me a suit of armor or a lance, I guess that would be fine, too.”
Against all odds, my parents held off on the Dark Age armaments and bought me a number of Penguin Classic books. Among my plunder was a bound copy of an essay by George Orwell/Eric Arthur Blair of the Animal Farm fame (”Some pigs lead a revolt against people, act like jerks, and play poker.”)
George’s work is entitled “Why I Write”, but before revealing why he writes, he lists four reasons why anyone would ever write:
1. Sheer egotism
2. Aesthetic enthusiasm
3. Historical impulse
4. Political purpose
George’s reason for writing? Number four (politics) and boy does George have an axe to grind. He uses over twenty pages to excoriate the British, writing for example, “England is the most class-ridden country under the sun. It is a land of snobbery and privilege, ruled largely by the old and the silly.” And of the English politicians he says, “What is to be expected of them is not treachery or physical cowardice, but stupidity, unconscious sabotage, an infallible instinct for doing the wrong thing.” Literary blood-lust sated, George launches into the main course of his essay; why we should all embrace socialism.
The time was 1941 and the Germans had, in May, begun to heavily bomb London. The English, just a year removed from the myopic command of Neville Chamberlain, were rather unprepared for the assault and were therefore badly suffering. George strongly believed that it was evil capitalism that was preventing England from succeeding in the conflict. “What this war has demonstrated is that private capitalism– that is, an economic system in which land, factories, mines and transport are owned privately and operated solely for profit– does not work.” He goes so far to declare that unless capitalism were immediately replaced by socialism, England was bound to lose the war.
Well, ol’ George was wrong and a short time later, prodded by the Japanese, the bottom-feeding, capitalist Americans arrived and whooped up on the Germans and the other Axis powers. That didn’t stop George from publishing the essay, however, the year after the war, in 1946.
No doubt, many of you will write and ask for a short primer on socialism. Here ya go!
Socialism: “common ownership of the means of production. … the State … owns everything, and everyone is a State employee. This does not mean that people are stripped of private possessions such as clothes and furniture, but it does mean that all productive good such as land, mines, ships and machinery are the property of the state. … [furthermore there is] approximate equality of incomes…, political democracy and abolition of all hereditary privilege”
Fascism*: Again, the State “is in control of everything. It controls investment, working hours, wages.” However, “The factory owner stills owns the factory, but he is for practical purposes reduced to the status of a manager.”
* Calling someone a Fascist Pig is a good fall back if you run out of other insults in a heated argument.